# Reef Clip Review

Decision key: `keep`, `edit`, `reject`, `hold`.

| Clip | Decision | Start | Rough Use | Caption Idea | Verification | Notes |
| --- | --- | ---: | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| `01_shark_bluewater_0550_muted.mp4` | keep | 00:05:50 | Shark pass; strong visual hook candidate. | A shark glides through Cuba Journal's 2016 reef archive. | Verify species and exact reef/location before public caption. | Keep from first review - no Castro in public framing. |
| `02_reef_fish_swarm_1550_muted.mp4` | reject | 00:15:50 | Reef fish movement; atmosphere / biodiversity. | A flash of reef life from Cuba Journal's 2016 archive. | Verify species and exact reef/location before public caption. | Rejected in first visual review - no Castro in public framing. |
| `03_reef_shark_close_2750_muted.mp4` | keep | 00:27:50 | Shark pass; strong visual hook candidate. | A shark glides through Cuba Journal's 2016 reef archive. | Verify species and exact reef/location before public caption. | Keep from first review - no Castro in public framing. |
| `04_grouper_shark_3550_muted.mp4` | keep | 00:35:50 | Grouper / shark / reef tableau; species IDs need verification. | A shark glides through Cuba Journal's 2016 reef archive. | Verify species and exact reef/location before public caption. | Keep from first review - no Castro in public framing. |
| `05_shark_pass_3950_muted.mp4` | keep | 00:39:50 | Shark pass; strong visual hook candidate. | A shark glides through Cuba Journal's 2016 reef archive. | Verify species and exact reef/location before public caption. | Keep from first review - no Castro in public framing. |
| `06_whale_shark_blue_4350_muted.mp4` | keep | 00:43:50 | Large spotted shark/fish in blue water; verify species before captioning. | A large spotted fish passes through blue water in Cuba Journal's reef archive. | Verify species and exact reef/location before public caption. | Keep from first review - no Castro in public framing. |
| `07_whale_shark_swim_4550_muted.mp4` | keep | 00:45:50 | Large spotted shark/fish in blue water; verify species before captioning. | A large spotted fish passes through blue water in Cuba Journal's reef archive. | Verify species and exact reef/location before public caption. | Keep from first review - no Castro in public framing. |

## Batch Notes

Do not present archive footage as current. Verify species and location before public captions. Review exports are muted; audio decisions happen later. Do not use Castro as the public-facing hook, title frame, caption frame, or social copy angle for this batch.

## Scratch Notes

no castro

## Outcome

- Keep: 6
- Edit: 0
- Hold: 0
- Reject: 1